On 1/21/08 at 8:17 AM, qazwart

gmail.com (David Weintraub) wrote:
>On Jan 18, 2008 1:40 PM, Paul Schinder <schinder

pobox.com> wrote:
>>I'm giving my Tungsten T5 up.
>
>And, I've given up on my Palm TX. I've been using Palms since the Palm
>III came out back in the late cretaceous period.
Pretty much the same here, except I'm going back even further,
to the Pilot 1000.
>However, after constant freezes, poor software, and finally an out of
>sync touch screen, I've said goodbye to Palm. Heck, it didn't even do
>a very good job of syncing with my Mac or PC.
There's still a few things I like better on the Palm vs. the
iPhone/Touch platform. The biggest thing is the lack of truly
synchronizing notes; there's also a few games I like on the Palm
platform. That said, I've been very disappointed in Palm
offerings over the last few years; everything since the original
Tungsten T/T2 has felt relatively cheaply made (and even those
didn't feel as solid as the old 505), and the new features have
been disappointing. (I thought the wireless networking would be
nice on the TX, but in practice it's turned out to be just about
useless. The problem is twofold: First, as I mentioned in my
Nokia 800 review, the Palm networking isn't built-in at a system
level, and you can't do things like installing software over the
internet. Second, the primary 'net applications, like Blazer,
are pretty sad compared to their iPhone/Touch equivalents.) I've
noticed reductions in stability in the last couple of
generations, as well. Finally, it seems like Palm's hardware
development has stagnated; the TX is the last pure PDA they've
released (and that was over two years ago!), the Treos have
changed very little, and the Centro is pretty much a warmed-over
Treo. (Which seems even harder to type on than the iPhone/Touch
is, playing around in the store.)
It's sad; I used to love Palms, and they stayed the most
Mac-friendly for the longest out of the PDAs. But unless they
pull something major out of their hat *soon* - and I mean
shipping, not announced and slipping off into limbo-land, like
Palm OS 6 - they're probably dead.
>My birthday is coming up pretty quick, and I am thinking of getting
>the iPod Touch as a PDA replacement for my Palm. WiFi is pretty
>ubiquitous in New York now, so I can use many webapss where I use to
>use Palm apps. And, with the release of the SDK at the end of
>February, I suspect we'll see quite a few more apps turning up.
If the majority of the unofficial 'jailbreak' hacked apps make
it over to the official SDK, the future there is looking pretty
good. There's a few nice games, a very nice terminal app (I hate
to say it, but it's better than the N800's, just because the
iPhone's screen keyboard is so much better than the N800's), a
nicely-done VNC client, a decent e-reader (*not* as nice as
FBReader on the N800, it doesn't handle long files very well at
all, and you have to break them up; fortunately, the HTML
versions of the Baen e-books come pre-broken into chapters), and
others I haven't had a chance to play with.
For my use, the Calender and Contacts apps are at least as good
as the Palm ones, though I've seen some complaints about
Contacts not being customizable and Calendar not having multiple
categories. The big thing I think is still missing is a Notes
function, or even just some kind of storable and viewable data,
that syncs with the desktop. We'll see if Apple finally gets the
existing Notes to sync with something on the desktop, or else
provides sync services support in the SDK so that third-parties
can do so.